Investigating Linguistic Relativity through Bilingualism: The Case of Grammatical Gender

 Investigating Linguistic Relativity through Bilingualism: The situation of Grammatical Gender Essay


Student Number: 11032901

Module Code: PC5003

Kousta, T. -T., Vinson, D. S., & Vigliocco, G. (2008). Investigating linguistic relativity through bilingualism: The case of grammatical gender. Diary of Trial and error Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 34 (4), 843-858.

Language may be the expression of feelings, thoughts, ideas and experience with the use of sounds or perhaps symbols (Goldstein, 2011). Whether we " think in language” or whether vocabulary shapes our thoughts is still a matter of big debate, today. There are two main paradigms underlying the relation among language and thought. On the one hand, the linguistic universality hypothesis, of which the origins can be traced in Chomsky's Universal Grammar (1978) suggesting which the system of concepts, conditions and rules are common features of most human different languages (Chomsky, 1975), proposes that the universal show of thought and knowledge precedes linguistic constraints that each language includes (Pae, 2012). On the other hand, the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis advocates that human cognition depends on dialect and that this relation creates discrepancies in thought throughout language neighborhoods (Wolff & Holmes, 2011). There are two forms of the latter hypothesis. The first, the more robust form of Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, named linguistic determinism, supports that language can determine the way all of us perceive and think about the community; while, the 2nd one, particularly linguistic relativism, is the sluggish form of the hypothesis and assumes that different languages encode diverse categories which speakers of different languages consequently think about the world in different methods (Fromkin, Rodman & Hyams, 2007). More over, Whorf (1956) took length from the best form of his theory when he believed that additional learning has the power of transforming or perhaps enhancing the speaker's worldview arguing intended for the benefits of linguistic pluralism. Yet , Stubbs (1997) argued that languages are generally not incompatible in the manner that it is possible to translate between them; therefore , bilinguals usually do not perceive the earth differently whenever they switch in one language to a different (Pavlenko, 2005). On the same say, Kousta ain al. (2008) tested the effectiveness of the language effects on experience by examining to what level bilingual loudspeakers develop semantic representation that are appropriate for their second language and what extent they are troubled by learning the second language through two trials. Specifically, that they investigate the bilingual experience in relation to a phenomenon, namely grammatical gender, and if the latter influences conceptual and semantic representations- knowledge about relationships among several types of elements, including, in this case, words and phrases. The grammatical gender is known as a formal category which labeling nouns while masculine, girly, neuter etc and its results are more likely to become obtained with languages which usually possesses two gender categories (masculine and feminine) and with frequent correspondence among grammatical and natural gender such as Italian language, French and Spanish. Research 1 was executed to elicit semantic substitution mistakes in British and German monolinguals. The hypothesis was that if grammatical gender boosts semantic likeness between subjective that discuss gender, then your monolingual Italian language speakers will certainly produce even more gender-preserving problems than monolingual English loudspeakers as in British the grammatical gender is definitely irrelevant. Kousta et 's. (2008) recruited 25 indigenous Italian loudspeakers for the first test and as a control selection of 26 linguists as English language language does not include grammatical sexuality. The material employed in the 1st experiment consists of 41 obstructs of 12 pictures of 27 common land pets (11 female and 18 masculine), each one of the pictures had been presented on a black and light background. The experiment was carried out beneath time pressure and consisted of two parts: in the first one,...

References: List

Chomsky, In. (1975). Reflections on vocabulary. New York: Pantheon Books

Fromkin, V., Rodman, R. & Hyams, D. (2007). An intro to Vocabulary. (8th ed). Boston: Thomson Wadsworth.

Goldstein, E. W. (2011) (3rd Ed). Cognitive Psychology: Hooking up Mind, Analysis and Every day Experience. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

Kousta, T. -T., Vinson, D. L., & Vigliocco, G. (2008). Investigating linguistic relativity through bilingualism: The situation of grammatical gender. Log of Trial and error Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 34 (4), 843-858.

Pae, They would. K. (2012) " Linguistic relativity revisited: the interaction between L1 and L2 in thinking, learning and production”, Mindset, Vol 3(1), pp. 49-56.

Pavlenko, A. (2005). Bilinguism and Thought. In Krol J. Farreneheit. &, sobre Groot, A. M. N. (Eds) Guide of Bilingualism: Psycholinguistic Techniques. New York: Oxford University Press

Perani, D. & Abutalebi, T. (2005). The neural foundation first and second language processing. Current View in Neurobiology, vol. 15, pp. 202-206.

Wolff, G. & Sherlock holmes, K. M. (2011). " Linguistic relativity”, Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science, volume. 2(3). g. 253-265.


The Premarital Communication Root base of Marriage Distress and Divorce: The First Five Years of Relationship Essay

The Premarital Connection Roots of Marital Stress and Divorce: The Initially Five A lot of Marriage Advantages Due to the excessive amount of marriages that end in…...

Use of First person point of view in «Raymond’s Run» and «Cathedral» Essay

The authors of " Raymond's Run" and " Cathedral", both make use of a first person perspective in their short stories. In " Raymond's Run", by Toni Genievre Bambara, the…...

The First World War Ended the European Dominance, superiority of the World Exploration Paper

The Initial World Warfare in the beginning with the twentieth 100 years is appreciated as horrific and the savagery of the human race. It was the clash involving…...

The Effect of Social Media on the English Language Essay

Student term: ……………. Pupil ID: ……………. The Effect of Social Media around the English Language 1 of 8 Desk Of Content: Abstract…...

Essay about Effective Advancements: Communication Abilities and failings

Effective Improvements: Communication Strengths and Weaknesses Communication is actually a necessity to human development. It commences biologically, just before we are created, continuing the others of our days and…...

Essay about Research Pitch On Financing Small And Moderate Scale Organization In Nigeria

п»їCONTENT OF PROPOSAL Study title Qualifications OF Pitch Question and Objective Techniques of analysis Opportunity. And limitation Plan of study Recommendations…...

Physics Pendulum Lab Statement Essay

Pendulum Raiyan Hassan SPH3U September 20, 2011 Introduction A pendulum is a unit which includes a mass attached with a string from a frictionless…...

Lord from the Flies and Human Nature Essay

Good and evil. These are generally two terms that everybody offers heard. One question that can arise coming from these two phrases is whether human beings are essentially…...

Organelles and Functions Article

Plant Cellular Organelles Information OrganelleDescription NucleusThe nucleus is made up of all of the genetic make-up in the cell and it is the control center with the cell NucleolusThe…...

Clark Sink Company Dissertation

Benedictine University MBA 683 Job Management 2013 Circumstance analysis Clark Water filters Company Yilei Zhu Clark Sink Company…...